🛡️ Certification

HMC vs HFA: What the Two UK Halal Logos Actually Mean

HMC says it accepts no stunning at all. HFA is understood to accept some. What each certifier has said, why the difference matters, and how to check which logo you are looking at.

A halal butcher shop front in England
A halal butcher shop front in England. Photo: Jonathan Thacker, CC BY-SA 2.0

The practical difference between the two main UK halal logos is stunning. The Halal Monitoring Committee (HMC) does not accept it. The Halal Food Authority (HFA) is understood to accept some forms of it. If you only eat meat from animals that were not stunned, the logo tells you which certifier to trust, and a generic "halal" sign does not.

What HMC says

HMC's FAQ answers the question "Does HMC accept and certify stunned meat or poultry?" with: "No. Part of our criteria is that animals are not stunned." In a 2018 statement about KFC, HMC went further, saying that "HMC since its inception has not accepted stunning/mechanical slaughter/gassing of animals based on advice from scholars." You can read both on HMC's site: the FAQ and the KFC statement, which is dated 14 December 2018.

What HFA says

We could not load the Halal Food Authority's website in a form we could read, so we cannot quote HFA's own position. What we can point to is HMC's 2018 statement, which says HMC's understanding is that some KFC branches are certified by HFA and that the poultry there is stunned and hand slaughtered. HFA's current standard on stunning, and on mechanical slaughter of poultry, is something to ask HFA directly, or to read on its site. Our HFA page records the sources we have found.

Why the difference exists

UK law requires animals to be stunned before slaughter unless they are slaughtered under religious rites. GOV.UK says that exemption applies to halal and kosher meat, with conditions such as an approved slaughterhouse and a Muslim slaughterer for halal. The same page notes that a significant proportion of halal meat comes from animals that are stunned. So halal certification in the UK covers both stunned and non-stunned meat, and it is the certifier's standard that tells you which.

Scholars differ on the question itself. Some accept stunning that does not kill the animal, as long as it is alive at the moment of slaughter. Others reject it entirely, as HMC does. Our answer on stunned meat sets out both views and does not pick one.

Checking which logo you are looking at

Look for the logo and a certificate with an expiry date. Search the business on the certifier's own website: HMC publishes lists of certified outlets and suppliers. Beware of logos that look similar but are not the official mark, and ask which supplier the meat comes from. The certification guide lists the other certifiers you may see, and the HMC page explains how to check an HMC certificate.

This guide summarises publicly stated positions and is not a religious ruling.

Hafiz Nasir Mehmood
Written by Hafiz Nasir Mehmood

Quran Hafiz and Islamic researcher.

Check a whole product

Scan a barcode, snap the label or paste the ingredients.

Keep reading

A sign advertising halal food

Certification · 3 min read

How to Get Halal Certified: UK Restaurants and Food Businesses

A step-by-step guide for UK restaurants, takeaways and food producers: choosing a halal certifier, what inspectors check, costs and renewals.

A halal butcher shop on a UK high street
1

Certification · 3 min read

How to Find a Halal Butcher You Can Trust

What to look for in a UK halal butcher: certificates, certifiers, stunning, where the meat comes from, and the questions worth asking before you buy.

An ingredients list with E-numbers on a sweets packet
2

E-numbers · 2 min read

Haram E-Numbers Watch List: The Halal Codes to Check

The handful of E-numbers that actually matter for halal — which are haram, which are doubtful, and how to tell from the label.