Colour

Is Carmine (Cochineal) Halal?

Haram

Carmine (cochineal) is haram. Insects and their by-products are forbidden according to Darul Ifta Birmingham, which cites all mainstream schools. Indonesia's MUI declared cochineal colourings halal (Fatwa No. 33 of 2011). The default setting avoids it; you can change this in your insect setting.

TypeColour
Comes fromCrushed insects.
Names on labels14

Names to look for on labels

  • carmine
  • cochineal
  • carminic acid
  • natural red 4
  • ci 75470
  • crimson lake

On labels from other countries

  • carmin
  • cochenille
  • karmin
  • cochinilla
  • cocciniglia
  • kırmızı karmin
  • كارمين
  • кармин

What to do

Avoid products containing this unless the pack clearly states a halal source or carries a recognised halal certification.

Scholars differ on carmine. The result follows your insect setting, which avoids it by default; change it in checking preferences. Shellac (E904) does not follow this setting. It is a secretion, not the insect itself, and scholars treat it differently, so it stays Doubtful either way.

More about carmine (cochineal)

Carmine is a red colour made from the crushed bodies of the cochineal insect. It is used in sweets, yoghurts, drinks, meat products and lipsticks, as E120 or carminic acid.

UK scholars are divided on insect-derived colours. Many certifiers avoid it. The label shows it as E120, carmine or cochineal.

Is carmine (cochineal) vegetarian or vegan?

No. Carmine (cochineal) comes from animals, so it is not vegetarian or vegan.

Found in 6 UK products we checked

Why we classify it this way

Haram Insects and their by-products are forbidden according to Darul Ifta Birmingham, which cites all mainstream schools. Indonesia's MUI declared cochineal colourings halal (Fatwa No. 33 of 2011). The default setting avoids it; you can change this in your insect setting.

Basis: Insect-derived; follows your setting. Made from insects. Scholars differ, so the result follows the insect setting in your checking preferences.

Different views

ViewResultWhy
Insects avoided (default) HaramDarul Ifta Birmingham: insects and their by-products are forbidden according to all mainstream schools.
Insect-derived allowed HalalIndonesia's MUI (Fatwa No. 33 of 2011) declares cochineal colourings halal if beneficial and not harmful.

Carmine is extracted from the insect itself. Shellac is a secretion, and scholars treat the two differently, so shellac is Doubtful and carmine follows your insect setting.

References

  • What Is the Dominant View on Shellac? (Fatwa 06106), Darul Ifta Birmingham, 11 June 2022. Says consuming shellac is prohibited because insects and their by-products are forbidden according to all mainstream schools, citing Al-Fatawa Al-Hindiyyah.
  • MUI: Cochineal Fatwa Decision Taken from the Opinions of Many Experts, Indonesian Council of Ulama (MUI), via LPPOM MUI, 29 September 2023. MUI Fatwa No. 33 of 2011 declares food and drink colourings from cochineal halal as long as they are beneficial and not harmful. The page also notes that a provincial Nahdlatul Ulama body discussed carmine as unclean, so views are not uniform.

Classification audited 3 November 2026. It has not been reviewed by a scholar. How classifications work · Suggest a correction

Check a whole product

Scan a barcode, snap the label or paste the ingredients.

Frequently asked questions

Is carmine (cochineal) halal?

Carmine (cochineal) is haram. Insects and their by-products are forbidden according to Darul Ifta Birmingham, which cites all mainstream schools. Indonesia's MUI declared cochineal colourings halal (Fatwa No. 33 of 2011). The default setting avoids it; you can change this in your insect setting.

Where does carmine (cochineal) come from?

Crushed insects.

Is carmine (cochineal) vegetarian or vegan?

No. Carmine (cochineal) comes from animals, so it is not vegetarian or vegan.

How we decide · Suggest a correction