Vinegar

Is wine vinegar halal? Red and white wine vinegar

Doubtful

Wine vinegar is doubtful (mushbooh). Scholars differ. The Hanafi view allows vinegar made from wine however it was made; the Shafi'i view allows it only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself; Hanbali and Maliki scholars do not allow wine to be turned into vinegar on purpose. Doubtful in the general setting, halal in the Hanafi setting.

TypeVinegar
Comes fromWine that has turned into vinegar.
Names on labels14

Names to look for on labels

  • red wine vinegar
  • white wine vinegar
  • balsamic vinegar
  • sherry vinegar
  • brandy vinegar
  • beer vinegar

On labels from other countries

  • vinaigre de vin
  • weinessig
  • wijnazijn
  • vinagre de vino
  • aceto di vino
  • vinagre de vinho
  • şarap sirkesi

What to do

Look for a halal logo, a "vegan" label, or a stated plant source on the pack. If none of these are present, you can contact the manufacturer and ask for the source.

More about wine vinegar

Wine vinegar is made by letting acetic acid bacteria convert the alcohol in wine into acetic acid. Red, white, sherry and champagne vinegars all follow this process. The finished vinegar contains several per cent acetic acid and very little alcohol.

Balsamic vinegar is a related product made from grape must, and cheaper balsamic condiments include wine vinegar. Wine vinegar is used in dressings, marinades, sauces, pickles and mayonnaise.

Is wine vinegar vegetarian or vegan?

Not always. Wine vinegar can be made from plant or animal sources, and labels rarely say which. A vegetarian or vegan label on the pack confirms a plant or synthetic source.

Found in 14 UK products we checked

See all 14 products with wine vinegar →

Why we classify it this way

Doubtful Scholars differ. The Hanafi view allows vinegar made from wine however it was made; the Shafi'i view allows it only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself; Hanbali and Maliki scholars do not allow wine to be turned into vinegar on purpose. Doubtful in the general setting, halal in the Hanafi setting.

Basis: Scholars differ. Recognised scholars or schools reach different conclusions. We show each view and do not present one as the only one.

The pack does not say whether the vinegar turned by itself or was made on purpose, so in the general setting it is Doubtful. The Hanafi setting shows it as Halal.

Different views

ViewResultWhy
Hanafi HalalWine that has become vinegar is permitted whether it changed by itself or was converted on purpose.
Shafi'i DoubtfulPermitted only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself; not if it was converted deliberately.
Hanbali HaramTurning wine into vinegar is not permitted, and the vinegar may not be drunk.
Maliki DoubtfulTurning wine into vinegar is not permitted, but the vinegar may be consumed once it has changed.

References

  • Ruling on vinegar made from wine (Fatwa 01631), Darul Ifta Birmingham. Sets out the four schools: Hanafi allows wine turned to vinegar by itself or deliberately; Shafi'i allows it only if it turned by itself; Hanbali does not allow turning wine into vinegar and does not allow drinking it; Maliki does not allow turning it but allows drinking it once changed.

Classification audited 3 November 2026. It has not been reviewed by a scholar. How classifications work · Suggest a correction

Read more

Wine vinegar at a glance

TypeMade fromHow we classify it
White wine vinegarWhite wineDoubtful: schools differ; Halal in the Hanafi setting
Red wine vinegarRed wineDoubtful: schools differ; Halal in the Hanafi setting
Balsamic vinegarGrape must, sometimes with wine vinegarDoubtful if wine vinegar is listed; check for added wine
Cider vinegarApple ciderHalal: not made from wine
Malt and spirit vinegarBarley or grain alcoholHalal: not made from wine

Why scholars differ on wine vinegar

Wine is haram, but vinegar is not wine. When bacteria turn alcohol into acetic acid, the drink changes its nature: it can no longer intoxicate and it is called by a different name. Scholars call this transformation (istihalah). The Prophet ﷺ said, "What a good condiment vinegar is" (Sahih Muslim 2051).

The schools agree that vinegar is a good food, but they do not agree on vinegar that was made from wine, and especially on wine that people turned into vinegar on purpose. We show each view below and do not present one as the only one.

Where scholars differ

SchoolPosition
HanafiVinegar made from wine is permitted whether the wine turned by itself or was converted on purpose
Shafi'iPermitted only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself, not if it was converted deliberately
HanbaliTurning wine into vinegar is not permitted, and the vinegar may not be drunk
MalikiTurning wine into vinegar is not permitted, but the vinegar may be consumed once it has changed

Source: Ruling on vinegar made from wine (Fatwa 01631), Darul Ifta Birmingham. This is a summary of that fatwa, not a ruling of our own.

Modern commercial wine vinegar is usually made deliberately, and the pack does not say how. That is why the general setting marks it Doubtful and the Hanafi setting marks it Halal. You can choose your school in settings.

Does wine vinegar contain alcohol?

Finished vinegar can contain a small residue of alcohol. The bigger concern is products that add wine to vinegar after it is made, such as some dressings, which should then list wine separately.

Balsamic vinegar

Traditional balsamic vinegar is made from cooked grape must that is aged, not from wine. Cheaper "balsamic vinegar of Modena" is usually grape must blended with wine vinegar, so the same differences apply. Check glazes and dressings for added wine or alcohol. See is balsamic vinegar halal?

Where you will find wine vinegar

Wine vinegar is common in salad dressings, mayonnaise, mustard, pickles, crisps seasoning and ready meals. Our checker treats plain vinegar (malt, cider, spirit, rice) as halal and wine vinegar as doubtful.

Frequently asked questions

Is white wine vinegar halal?

It depends on the school you follow. Hanafi scholars permit it. Shafi'i scholars permit it only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself, and Hanbali and Maliki scholars do not permit turning wine into vinegar on purpose. We mark it Doubtful.

Is red wine vinegar haram?

Red wine vinegar follows the same differences as white wine vinegar. We do not call it haram, because the schools do not agree that it is.

Is balsamic vinegar halal?

Balsamic vinegar made only from grape must contains no wine vinegar. Many supermarket versions blend in wine vinegar, so the same differences apply. Check balsamic glazes and dressings for added wine.

Is cider vinegar halal?

Yes. Apple cider vinegar is made from apples, not from wine, so the wine question does not arise.

Does wine vinegar make food haram?

Not on its own. Food containing wine vinegar is Doubtful, not Haram, and it is Halal in the Hanafi setting. It is Haram if it also contains wine or another haram ingredient.

Check a whole product

Scan a barcode, snap the label or paste the ingredients.

Quick answers

Is wine vinegar halal?

Wine vinegar is doubtful (mushbooh). Scholars differ. The Hanafi view allows vinegar made from wine however it was made; the Shafi'i view allows it only if the wine turned to vinegar by itself; Hanbali and Maliki scholars do not allow wine to be turned into vinegar on purpose. Doubtful in the general setting, halal in the Hanafi setting.

Where does wine vinegar come from?

Wine that has turned into vinegar.

Is wine vinegar vegetarian or vegan?

Not always. Wine vinegar can be made from plant or animal sources, and labels rarely say which. A vegetarian or vegan label on the pack confirms a plant or synthetic source.

Is wine vinegar halal for Hanafis?

In the Hanafi school only fish is clearly permitted from the sea, so many Hanafis treat these as doubtful or avoid them. Choose the Hanafi setting to see this in the checker.

Related ingredients

How we decide · Suggest a correction